// Copyright Paul A. Bristow 2007 // Copyright John Maddock 2006 // Use, modification and distribution are subject to the // Boost Software License, Version 1.0. // (See accompanying file LICENSE_1_0.txt // or copy at http://www.boost.org/LICENSE_1_0.txt) // binomial_examples_quiz.cpp // Simple example of computing probabilities and quantiles for a binomial random variable // representing the correct guesses on a multiple-choice test. // source http://www.stat.wvu.edu/SRS/Modules/Binomial/test.html //[binomial_quiz_example1 /*` A multiple choice test has four possible answers to each of 16 questions. A student guesses the answer to each question, so the probability of getting a correct answer on any given question is 1/4 = 0.25. The conditions of the binomial experiment are assumed to be met: n = 16 questions constitute the trials; each question results in one of two possible outcomes (correct or incorrect); the probability of being correct is 0.25 and is constant if no knowledge about the subject is assumed; the questions are answered independently if the student's answer to a question in no way influences his/her answer to another question. The number of correct answers, X, is distributed as a binomial random variable with binomial distribution parameters n = 16 and p = 0.25. The program below displays the probabilities for each of the 17 possible outcomes, i.e., for X = 0, 1, ..., 16, in a line chart. First we need to be able to use the binomial distribution constructor (and some std input/output, of course) */ #include using boost::math::binomial; #include using std::cout; using std::endl; using std::ios; using std::flush; using std::left; using std::right; using std::fixed; #include using std::setw; using std::setprecision; //][/binomial_quiz_example1] //[binomial_confidence_limits void confidence_limits_on_frequency(unsigned trials, unsigned successes) { // trials = Total number of trials, successes = Total number of observed successes. // Calculate confidence limits for an observed // frequency of occurrence that follows a binomial distribution. // Print out general info: cout << "___________________________________________\n" "2-Sided Confidence Limits For Success Ratio\n" "___________________________________________\n\n"; cout << setprecision(7); cout << setw(40) << left << "Number of Observations" << "= " << trials << "\n"; cout << setw(40) << left << "Number of successes" << "= " << successes << "\n"; cout << setw(40) << left << "Sample frequency of occurrence" << "= " << double(successes) / trials << "\n"; // Define a table of significance levels: double alpha[] = { 0.5, 0.25, 0.1, 0.05, 0.01, 0.001, 0.0001, 0.00001 }; // // Print table header: // cout << "\n\n" "___________________________________________\n" "Confidence Lower Upper\n" " Value (%) Limit Limit\n" "___________________________________________\n"; for(unsigned i = 0; i < sizeof(alpha)/sizeof(alpha[0]); ++i) { // Now print out the data for the table rows. // Confidence value: cout << fixed << setprecision(3) << setw(10) << right << 100 * (1-alpha[i]); // Calculate bounds: double l = binomial::estimate_lower_bound_on_p(trials, successes, alpha[i]/2); double u = binomial::estimate_upper_bound_on_p(trials, successes, alpha[i]/2); // And print limits: cout << fixed << setprecision(5) << setw(15) << right << l; cout << fixed << setprecision(5) << setw(15) << right << u << endl; } cout << endl; } // void confidence_limits_on_frequency() //] [/binomial_confidence_limits] //[binomial_quiz_example2 int main() { try { cout << "Binomial distribution example - guessing in a quiz." << endl; /*` The number of correct answers, X, is distributed as a binomial random variable with binomial distribution parameters n = 16 and p = 0.25. */ cout.precision(5); // Might be able to calculate a best value for this? int questions = 16; int answers = 4; // possible answers to each question. double success_fraction = (double)answers / (double)questions; // If a random guess. // Caution: = answers / questions would be zero (because they are integers)! int pass_score = 11; /*` Construct our Binomial distribution. */ binomial quiz(questions, success_fraction); /*` and display the parameters we used. */ cout << "In a quiz with " << quiz.trials() << " questions and with a probability of guessing right of " << quiz.success_fraction() * 100 << " %" << " or 1 in " << static_cast(1. / quiz.success_fraction()) << endl; /*` Show some probabilities of just guessing: these don't give any encouragement to guessers! */ cout << "Probability of getting none right is " << pdf(quiz, 0) << endl; // 0.010023 cout << "Probability of getting at least one right is " << 1 - pdf(quiz, 1) << endl; // 0.94655 cout << "Probability of getting none or one right is " << pdf(quiz, 0) + pdf(quiz, 1) << endl; // 0.063476 cout << "Probability of getting exactly one right is " << pdf(quiz, 1) << endl; cout << "Probability of getting exactly 11 right is " << pdf(quiz, 11) << endl; cout << "Probability of getting > 10 right (to pass) is " << cdf(complement(quiz, 10)) << endl; // Using Binomial probabilities. cout << "The probability of getting all the answers wrong by chance is " << pdf(quiz, 0) << endl; cout << "The probability of getting all the answers right by chance is " << pdf(quiz, questions) << endl; cout << "The probability of getting exactly " << pass_score << " answers right by guessing is " << pdf(quiz, pass_score) << endl << endl; cout << "The probability of getting less then " << pass_score << "(< " << pass_score << ") answers right by guessing is " << cdf(quiz, pass_score) << endl; cout << "The probability of getting at least " << pass_score << "(>= " << pass_score << ") answers right by guessing is " << cdf(complement(quiz, pass_score-1)) << " only 1 in " << 1/cdf(complement(quiz, pass_score-1)) << endl; /*` Tabulate probability versus number right. */ cout << "\n" "Guessed right Probability" << right << endl; for (int successes = 0; successes <= questions; successes++) { double probability = pdf(quiz, successes); cout << setw(2) << successes << " " << probability << endl; } cout << endl; cout << "\n" "At most (<=)""\n""Guessed right Probability" << right << endl; for (int score = 0; score <= questions; score++) { cout << setw(2) << score << " " << cdf(quiz, score) << endl; } cout << endl; cout << "\n" "At least (>=)""\n""Guessed right Probability" << right << endl; for (int score = 0; score <= questions; score++) { cout << setw(2) << score << " " << cdf(complement(quiz, score)) << endl; } /*` Calculate the probability of getting a range of guesses right, first by adding the exact probabilities of each of low ... high. */ int low = 3; int high = 5; double sum = 0.; for (int i = low; i <= high; i++) { sum += pdf(quiz, i); } cout << "The probability of getting between " << low << " and " << high << " answers right by guessing is " << sum << endl; // 0.61323 /*` Or, better, we can use the difference of cdfs instead: */ cout << "The probability of getting between " << low << " and " << high << " answers right by guessing is " << cdf(quiz, high) - cdf(quiz, low - 1) << endl; // 0.61323 // And a few more combinations of high and low choices: low = 1; high = 6; cout << "The probability of getting between " << low << " and " << high << " answers right by guessing is " << cdf(quiz, high) - cdf(quiz, low - 1) << endl; // 1 and 6 P= 0.91042 low = 1; high = 8; cout << "The probability of getting between " << low << " and " << high << " answers right by guessing is " << cdf(quiz, high) - cdf(quiz, low - 1) << endl; // 1 <= x 8 P = 0.9825 low = 4; high = 4; cout << "The probability of getting between " << low << " and " << high << " answers right by guessing is " << cdf(quiz, high) - cdf(quiz, low - 1) << endl; // 4 <= x 4 P = 0.22520 low = 3; high = 5; cout << "The probability of getting between " << low << " and " << high << " answers right by guessing is " << cdf(quiz, high) - cdf(quiz, low - 1) << endl; // P 3 to 5 right /*` Using Binomial distribution moments, we can say more about the spread of results from guessing. */ cout << "By guessing, on average, one can expect to get " << mean(quiz) << " correct answers." << endl; cout << "Standard deviation is " << standard_deviation(quiz) << endl; cout << "So about 2/3 will lie within 1 standard deviation and get between " << ceil(mean(quiz) - standard_deviation(quiz)) << " and " << floor(mean(quiz) + standard_deviation(quiz)) << " correct." << endl; cout << "Mode (the most frequent) is " << mode(quiz) << endl; cout << "Skewness is " << skewness(quiz) << endl; /*` Show the use of quantiles (percentiles or percentage points) for a few probability levels: */ cout << "Quantiles" << endl; cout << "Quartiles " << quantile(quiz, 0.25) << " to " << quantile(complement(quiz, 0.25)) << endl; // Quartiles 2.2821 4.6212 cout << "1 sd " << quantile(quiz, 0.33) << " to " << quantile(quiz, 0.67) << endl; // 1 sd 2.6654 4.1935 cout << "Deciles " << quantile(quiz, 0.1) << " to " << quantile(complement(quiz, 0.1))<< endl; // Deciles 1.3487 5.7583 cout << "5 to 95% " << quantile(quiz, 0.05) << " to " << quantile(complement(quiz, 0.05))<< endl; // 5 to 95% 0.83739 6.4559 cout << "2.5 to 97.5% " << quantile(quiz, 0.025) << " to " << quantile(complement(quiz, 0.025)) << endl; // 2.5 to 97.5% 0.42806 7.0688 cout << "2 to 98% " << quantile(quiz, 0.02) << " to " << quantile(complement(quiz, 0.02)) << endl; // 2 to 98% 0.31311 7.7880 cout << "If guessing then percentiles 1 to 99% will get " << quantile(quiz, 0.01) << " to " << quantile(complement(quiz, 0.01)) << " right." << endl; //] [/binomial_quiz_example2] //[discrete_quantile_real /*` The quantiles values are controlled by the discrete quantile policy chosen. The default is `integer_round_outwards`, so the lower quantile is rounded down, and the upper quantile is rounded up. We can control the policy for all distributions by #define BOOST_MATH_DISCRETE_QUANTILE_POLICY real at the head of the program would make this policy apply to this *one, and only*, translation unit. Or we can create a (typedef for) policy that has discrete quantiles real. */ using namespace boost::math::policies; /*` Convenient for all policy and typelist values like discrete_quantile. */ using namespace boost::math; /*` for binomial_distribution Or to be more specific, to avoid 'using namespaces ...' statements: */ using boost::math::policies::policy; using boost::math::policies::discrete_quantile; using boost::math::policies::real; using boost::math::policies::integer_round_outwards; // Default. typedef boost::math::policies::policy > real_quantile_policy; /*` Add a binomial distribution called real_quantile_binomial that uses real_quantile_policy. */ using boost::math::binomial_distribution; typedef binomial_distribution real_quantile_binomial; /*` Construct a distribution of this custom real_quantile_binomial distribution; */ real_quantile_binomial quiz_real(questions, success_fraction); /*` And use this to show some quantiles - that now have real rather than integer values. */ cout << "Real Quartiles " << quantile(quiz_real, 0.25) << " to " << quantile(complement(quiz_real, 0.25)) << endl; // Real Quartiles 2.2821 to 4.6212 //] [/discrete_quantile_real] //[binomial_quiz_example3 /*` Now we can repeat the confidence intervals for various confidences 1 - alpha, probability as % = 100 * (1 - alpha[i]), so alpha 0.05 = 95% confidence. */ double alpha[] = {0.5, 0.33, 0.25, 0.1, 0.05, 0.01, 0.001, 0.0001, 0.00001}; cout << "\n\n" "Confidence % Lower Upper ""\n"; for (unsigned int i = 0; i < sizeof(alpha)/sizeof(alpha[0]); ++i) { cout << fixed << setprecision(3) << setw(10) << right << 100 * (1 - alpha[i]); double l = real_quantile_binomial::estimate_lower_bound_on_p(questions, answers, alpha[i]/2); double u = real_quantile_binomial::estimate_upper_bound_on_p(questions, answers, alpha[i]/2); cout << fixed << setprecision(5) << setw(15) << right << l; cout << fixed << setprecision(5) << setw(15) << right << u << endl; } cout << endl; // static RealType estimate_lower_bound_on_p(RealType trials, RealType successes, RealType probability) int successes = 11; cout << "Success fraction " << quiz.success_fraction() << ", " << quiz.trials() << " correct needed, " << successes << " successes " << endl; cout << "Lower bound = " << binomial::estimate_lower_bound_on_p(quiz.trials(), successes, 0.05) << endl; // 0.51560 // Bounds now 0.45165 to 0.86789 ???? // Or equivalently: cout << "Lower bound = " << quiz.estimate_lower_bound_on_p(quiz.trials(), successes, 0.05) << endl; // 0.51560 cout << "Upper bound = " << quiz.estimate_upper_bound_on_p(quiz.trials(), successes, 0.05) << endl; // 0.86789 // Print a table of showing upper and lower bounds for a range of confidence levels. confidence_limits_on_frequency(20, 2); // 20 trials, 2 successes confidence_limits_on_frequency(200, 20); confidence_limits_on_frequency(2000, 200); } catch(const std::exception& e) { // Always useful to include try & catch blocks because // default policies are to throw exceptions on arguments that cause // errors like underflow, overflow. // Lacking try & catch blocks, the program will abort without a message below, // which may give some helpful clues as to the cause of the exception. std::cout << "\n""Message from thrown exception was:\n " << e.what() << std::endl; } return 0; } // int main() //] [/binomial_quiz_example3] /* Output is: Binomial distribution example - guessing in a quiz. In a quiz with 16 and with a probability of guessing right of 25 % or 1 in 4 Probability of getting none right is 0.010023 Probability of getting at least one right is 0.98998 Probability of getting exactly one right is 0.053454 Guessed right Probability 0 0.010023 1 0.053454 2 0.13363 3 0.20788 4 0.2252 5 0.18016 6 0.1101 7 0.052427 8 0.01966 9 0.0058253 10 0.0013592 11 0.00024713 12 3.4324e-005 13 3.5204e-006 14 2.5146e-007 15 1.1176e-008 16 2.3283e-010 By guessing, on average, one can expect to get 4 correct answers. Standard deviation is 1.7321 So about 2/3 will lie within 1 standard deviation and get between 3 and 5 correct. Mode (the most frequent) is 4 Skewness is 0.28868 The probability of getting all the answers wrong by chance is 0.010023 The probability of getting all the answers right by chance is 2.3283e-010 The probability of getting exactly 11 answers right by guessing is 0.00024713 The probability of getting at most 11(<= 11) answers right by guessing is 0.99996 The probability of getting at least 11(>= 11) answers right by guessing is 3.8107e-005 At most (<=) Guessed right Probability 0 0.010023 1 0.063476 2 0.19711 3 0.40499 4 0.63019 5 0.81035 6 0.92044 7 0.97287 8 0.99253 9 0.99836 10 0.99971 11 0.99996 12 1 13 1 14 1 15 1 16 1 At least (>=) Guessed right Probability 0 0.98998 1 0.93652 2 0.80289 3 0.59501 4 0.36981 5 0.18965 6 0.079557 7 0.02713 8 0.0074697 9 0.0016445 10 0.00028524 11 3.8107e-005 12 3.7833e-006 13 2.6287e-007 14 1.1409e-008 15 2.3283e-010 16 0 The probability of getting between 3 and 5 answers right by guessing is 0.61323 The probability of getting between 3 and 5 answers right by guessing is 0.61323 The probability of getting between 1 and 6 answers right by guessing is 0.91042 The probability of getting between 1 and 8 answers right by guessing is 0.98251 The probability of getting between 4 and 4 answers right by guessing is 0.2252 Quantiles Quartiles 2 to 5 1 sd 2 to 5 Deciles 1 to 6 5 to 95% 0 to 7 2.5 to 97.5% 0 to 8 2 to 98% 0 to 8 If guessing then percentiles 1 to 99% will get 0 to 8 right. Real Quartiles 2.2821 to 4.6212 Using quantiles: p plim 0.01 0.010022595757618546 q qlim 0.98999999999999999 -0.98997740424238145 com 99% 0 0 Confidence % Lower Upper 50.000 0.16108 0.36424 67.000 0.13651 0.40078 75.000 0.12318 0.42258 90.000 0.09025 0.48440 95.000 0.07266 0.52377 99.000 0.04545 0.59913 99.900 0.02427 0.68125 99.990 0.01329 0.74363 99.999 0.00737 0.79236 Success fraction 0.25000, 16.00000 trials Lower bound = 0.45165 Lower bound = 0.45165 Upper bound = 0.86789 ___________________________________________ 2-Sided Confidence Limits For Success Ratio ___________________________________________ Number of Observations = 20 Number of successes = 2 Sample frequency of occurrence = 0.1000000 ___________________________________________ Confidence Lower Upper Value (%) Limit Limit ___________________________________________ 50.000 0.04812 0.18675 75.000 0.03078 0.23163 90.000 0.01807 0.28262 95.000 0.01235 0.31698 99.000 0.00530 0.38713 99.900 0.00164 0.47093 99.990 0.00051 0.54084 99.999 0.00016 0.60020 ___________________________________________ 2-Sided Confidence Limits For Success Ratio ___________________________________________ Number of Observations = 200 Number of successes = 20 Sample frequency of occurrence = 0.1000000 ___________________________________________ Confidence Lower Upper Value (%) Limit Limit ___________________________________________ 50.000 0.08462 0.11824 75.000 0.07580 0.12959 90.000 0.06726 0.14199 95.000 0.06216 0.15021 99.000 0.05293 0.16698 99.900 0.04343 0.18756 99.990 0.03641 0.20571 99.999 0.03095 0.22226 ___________________________________________ 2-Sided Confidence Limits For Success Ratio ___________________________________________ Number of Observations = 2000 Number of successes = 200 Sample frequency of occurrence = 0.1000000 ___________________________________________ Confidence Lower Upper Value (%) Limit Limit ___________________________________________ 50.000 0.09536 0.10491 75.000 0.09228 0.10822 90.000 0.08916 0.11172 95.000 0.08720 0.11399 99.000 0.08344 0.11850 99.900 0.07921 0.12385 99.990 0.07577 0.12845 99.999 0.07282 0.13256 Build Time 0:03 */